Monarch Resources for Teachers


Ecological Interactions and Management Plan Performance Package

Standard  |  Assessment Task 1  |   Assessment Task 2  |   Performance Packages


Learning Area: Scientific Applications & Inquiry (partial)
Content Standard: Living Systems & Inquiry
Level: Middle

Standard

A student shall understand interactions and interdependence of living systems.
What students should know:
2.Understand plants, animals, and microorganisms
    a. diversity and adaptation of organisms
    b. populations and ecosystems.
3.Understand dynamic effect of humans interacting with the environment .

What students should do:
1. Formulate questions to be answered based on systematic observation
2. Design and conduct investigations and field studies
3. Analyze data to support or refute hypotheses:
    a. identify patterns in data
    b. compare results to known scientific theories, current models and/or personal experience
    c. consider multiple interpretations of data
4. Describe how a premise is supported by scientific concepts, principles, theories or laws
5. Create a model to illustrate a contemporary or historical concept, principle, theory, or law.

A student shall demonstrate the ability to gather information to answer a scientific or social science question.
What students should do:
2. Gather information from direct observations, interviews, or surveys
    a. frame a question
    b. collect and record data through observation, interviews, or surveys
    c. recording and organize information
    d. evaluate the question based on findings

Large Processes/Concepts: (Create a graphic or list of items in the process and check those addressed in this package)

Inquiry - Direct Observation Scientific Applications
Feasibility
Data Organization
Conclusions
Data Collection
Data Display
Design & conduct scientific investigation
through systematic observations
Communicate & defend a scientific argument
Use technology and mathematics to improve
investigations and communication

Description of Student Performances (Tasks)

Task 1: Interaction Study Task
Students will select a study area, observe and record interaction between living organisms and on-living objects, and report their findings using a map and logbook.

Task 2: Management Plan Task
Upon reviewing results of the first task, students will focus on and analyze particular interactions which affect monarch butterflies (or another species), develop a management plan to enhance monarch habitat, and prepare a presentation using a pamphlet, video or information center.

Note: This package was written to focus on monarch butterflies and their interactions with their living and non-living environment, but other insects may be substituted as focal organisms. The Monarchs in the Classroom Curriculum and monarch larvae may be obtained from Dr. Karen Oberhauser, Univ. of MN (oberh001@tc.umn.edu)

Scoring Criteria:

4 = Performance on this standard achieves and exceeds expectations of high standard work.
3 = Performance on this standard meets the expectations of high standard work
2 = Work on this standard has been completed, but all or part of the student's performance is below high standard level.
1 = Work on this standard has been completed, but performance is substantially below high standard level.
No package score is recorded until ALL parts of the package have been completed.

 


Assessment Task 1

Learning Area: Scientific Applications & Inquiry (partial)
Content Standard:
Living Systems & Inquiry
Level:
Middle
Task Title: Ecological Interactions Study

Standard

A student shall understand interactions and interdependence of living systems.
What students should know:
2.Understand plants, animals, and microorganisms
    a. diversity and adaptation of organisms
    b. populations and ecosystems.
3.Understand dynamic effect of humans interacting with the environment .

What students should do:
1. Formulate questions to be answered based on systematic observation
2. Design and conduct investigations and field studies
3. Analyze data to support or refute hypotheses:
    a. identify patterns in data
    b. compare results to known scientific theories, current models and/or personal experience
    c. consider multiple interpretations of data
4. Describe how a premise is supported by scientific concepts, principles, theories or laws
5. Create a model to illustrate a contemporary or historical concept, principle, theory, or law.

A student shall demonstrate the ability to gather information to answer a scientific or social science question.
What students should do:
2. Gather information from direct observations, interviews, or surveys
    a. frame a question
    b. collect and record data through observation, interviews, or surveys
    c. recording and organize information
    d. evaluate the question based on findings

Large Processes/Concepts: (Create a graphic or list of items in the process and check those addressed in this package)

Inquiry - Direct Observation Scientific Applications
Feasibility
Data Organization
Conclusions
Data Collection
Data Display
Design & conduct scientific investigation through systematic observations
Communicate & defend a scientific argument
Use technology and mathematics to improve investigations and communication

 

Remember design principles:
* let kids know where they are headed and why
* hook the kids
* make kids maximally self sufficient
* provide opportunity to reflect and rethink
* provide opportunity to revise and refine
* require individual accountability
* make it rigorous and rewarding for all

Products:

Task Description:

Overview:
Students will select a study area, observe and record interaction between living organisms and on-living objects, and report their findings using a map and log book.

  1. In groups of three, students will select three 30m x 30m plots of land that share part or all of a border (are connected to each other). Each student will be responsible for one plot. The plots should be representative of the neighborhood of the school and should be at least 70% free of buildings, roads, parking lots, etc.
  2. In their logbooks, students will record the address, city, county, state, latitude and longitude of their plot.
  3. Using graph paper, each student will draw to scale, a map of his or her plot of land. Indicate the locations of plants, animals, and all non-living objects. Include a key that indicates the identity and number of each component of the plot. Use colors and shapes to help enhance the map. Indicate all human construction or manipulation of the area.
  4. A minimum of three observations of the plot must be made at different times of the day in order to increase the chances of seeing animals. Students should be sure to include observations of insects.
  5. Each student will list the amounts (numbers or % coverage) of living organisms and non-living objects. An example of a plant list is: 60% of the area is mowed grass with scattered clover and dandelions; 10% is a flower garden that includes day lilies, daisies, hosta, and impatiens; there are 3 milkweed plants, 2 oak trees, and 1 spruce tree.
  6. Students will identify organisms and objects by name. If something is not identifiable, use drawings or rubbings, which must be included with the list.
  7. Before collecting data, students must design an appropriate data table with the proper labels for the rows and columns. Units of measure, if appropriate, should be included.
  8. Students will describe 10 interactions between living organisms. Some examples are: a bird using a tree as a perch, a bird eating an insect, or a bee getting nectar from a flower.
  9. In their logbook, students will classify the interactions in a data table using the scientific terms mutualism, commensalism, predation, herbivory, parasitism, and competition.
  10. In their logbooks, students will record observations of 6 interactions between a living organism and a non-living object. Some examples: a bird nest in the eave of a house, mosquitoes living in the water trapped in an old tire.
  11. Together, the 3 student partners will summarize their data by listing similarities and differences of their 3 plots. The summary should include a list of the numbers of each type of organism.
  12. The student partners will make a 2-3 minute presentation to the class sharing the information about the 3 plots.
Give students clear step by step directions that could be used in your absence.
*Identify purpose
*Identify or help kids identify their role
*Identify or help kids identify audience
*Identify the situation
*Identify the evidence-allowing students to choose the format
*Identify criteria upon which evidence will be assessed
Also provide kids with tools and strategies to demonstrate their learning.

 

Special Notes for Teachers:

  1. Ecology Curriculum lessons 1, 2, 3, 6 and 7; and Conservation lessons 1, 2 and 4 in the Monarchs in the Classroom Curriculum Guide for Middle School would augment this task.
  2. Teachers may create a log book for students to complete. See sample in Appendix 1.
  3. In order to accomplish this assessment students need to have prior knowledge in basic ecology: food chains, ecosystems, and life cycles.
  4. Selected land plots need to be accessible by students in the morning, midday and evening. It is most advantageous if the plots are adjacent to promote student interdependence and to increase the study areas.
  5. This task addresses Grades 5-8 National Education Content Standards for the following areas:

Living Systems: Regulation and Behavior

  • All organisms must be able to obtain and use resources, grow, reproduce, and maintain stable internal conditions while living in a constantly changing environment
  • An organism’s behavior evolves through adaptation to its environment

Populations and Ecosystems

  • A population consists of all individual of a species that occur together at a given place and time. All populations living together and the physical factors with which they interact compose and ecosystem.
  • The number of organisms an ecosystem can support depends on the resources available and abiotic factors.

Inquiry – Abilities Necessary to do Scientific Inquiry

  • Design and conduct a scientific investigation.
  • Use appropriate tools and techniques to gather, analyze, and interpret data.
  • Develop descriptions, explanations, predictions and models using evidence.
  • Think critically and logically to make the relationships between evidence and explanations.
  • Recognize and analyze alternative explanations and predictions.
  • Communicate scientific procedures and explanations.

 

**Download Task 1 Checklist (Word 97 File)
**Preview Task 1 Checklist
(print this page if your computer cannot read Word97 files)

**Task 1 Appendix:  Sample Field Study Log Book (print these pages for the example log book)


Assessment Task 2

Learning Area: Scientific Applications & Inquiry (partial)
Content Standard: Living Systems & Inquiry
Level:
Middle
Task Title:
Land Management Plan

Standard 

A student shall understand interactions and interdependence of living systems.
What students should know:
2.Understand plants, animals, and microorganisms
    a. diversity and adaptation of organisms
    b. populations and ecosystems.
3.Understand dynamic effect of humans interacting with the environment
.

What students should do:
1. Formulate questions to be answered based on systematic observation
2. Design and conduct investigations and field studies
3. Analyze data to support or refute hypotheses:
    a. identify patterns in data
    b. compare results to known scientific theories, current models and/or personal experience
    c. consider multiple interpretations of data

4. Describe how a premise is supported by scientific concepts, principles, theories or laws
5. Create a model to illustrate a contemporary or historical concept, principle, theory, or law.

A student shall demonstrate the ability to gather information to answer a scientific or social science question.
What students should do:

2. Gather information from direct observations, interviews, or surveys
    a. frame a question
    b. collect and record data through observation, interviews, or surveys
    c. recording and organize information
    d. evaluate the question based on findings

Large Processes/Concepts: (Create a graphic or list of items in the process and check those addressed in this package)

Inquiry - Direct Observation Scientific Applications
Feasibility
Data Organization
Conclusions
Data Collection
Data Display
Design & conduct scientific investigation through systematic observations
Communicate & defend a scientific argument
Use technology and mathematics to improve investigations and communication

 

Remember design principles:
* let kids know where they are headed and why
* hook the kids
* make kids maximally self sufficient
* provide opportunity to reflect and rethink
* provide opportunity to revise and refine
* require individual accountability
* make it rigorous and rewarding for all

Product/Evidence of Learning:

  • Log book
  • Presentation with pamphlet, video, or information center

Task Description:

Overview:
Upon reviewing results of the first task, students will focus on and analyze particular interactions which affect monarch butterflies and develop a management plan that will enhance monarch habitat and prepare a presentation using a pamphlet, video or information center.

  1. Students will take on the role as members of the Monarch (or other organism) Protection Agency. Their team has an Environmental Interaction Study, which details the organisms and objects located at a designated study site. (Result of Task One)
  2. Students will analyze research findings from task one. In their log book, they will list 5 ways that the living and non-living components and their interactions would influence monarch survival at each stage of its life cycle. Example: Application of herbicide (broad leaf killer) will destroy milkweed (larva food) and possibly nectar producing flowers.
  3. In their log book, students will rank the list of things that might impact the Monarch from 1 to 5 with 1 being the one with the most significance.
  4. In their log book, students will write a short explanation of why each of these is selected and ranked in this order. Thoughts should be included of short and long term consequences for monarchs in their study area.
  5. Students will determine how this area can improve its ability to support monarchs. In their log book, they will list 5 suggestions and reasons for these changes. Students should be reminded to be sure to include alternative solutions for their ideas. Example: If weeds are no longer sprayed, how will the weeds be controlled?
  6. Students will design a presentation that would convince the land owners to make adjustments to their current ways of managing the land so that it is better at supporting certain needs of the monarchs. Considerations should be made of the cost, time schedule, long term affects, other alternative solutions, and how the plan will make a difference.
  7. The presentation should be designed to persuade the land owner to make changes. Presentations should utilize one of the following as part of the group presentation: a pamphlet, a video, information center, or a multimedia show.
Give students clear step by step directions that could be used in your absence.
*Identify purpose
*Identify or help kids identify their role
*Identify or help kids identify audience
*Identify the situation
*Identify the evidence-allowing students to choose the format
*Identify criteria upon which evidence will be assessed
Also provide kids with tools and strategies to demonstrate their learning.

Special Notes for Teachers:

  1. Life Cycle Curriculum lessons 2 and 5; Ecology lessons 1, 2, 6 and 7; and Conservation lessons 1, 2, 3 and 4 in the Monarchs in the Classroom Curriculum Guide for Middle School would augment this task.
  2. In order to accomplish this assessment students need to have prior knowledge in basic ecology: food chains, ecosystems, and the monarch butterfly life cycle.
  3. This task can be adapted for any organism.
  4. Topics for further study in Task 2 might include the following: the use of pesticides, monarch friendly gardening, landscaping and monocultures, the maintenance of open areas (roads, edges of parks) and agricultural practices.
  5. This task addresses grades 5-8 National Education Content Standards for the following areas:

Living Systems: Regulation and Behavior

  • All organisms must be able to obtain and use resources, grow, reproduce, and maintain stable internal conditions while living in a constantly changing environment

Populations and Ecosystems

  • A population consists of all individual of a species that occur together at a given place and time. All populations living together and the physical factors with which they interact compose and ecosystem.
  • The number of organisms an ecosystem can support depends on the resources available and abiotic factors.

Inquiry – Abilities Necessary to do Scientific Inquiry

  • Design and conduct a scientific investigation.
  • Use appropriate tools and techniques to gather, analyze, and interpret data.
  • Develop descriptions, explanations, predictions and models using evidence.
  • Think critically and logically to make the relationships between evidence and explanations.
  • Recognize and analyze alternative explanations and predictions.
  • Communicate scientific procedures and explanations.

 

**Download Task 2 Checklist (Word 97 File)
**Preview Task 2 Checklist
(print this page if your computer cannot read Word97 files)

**Log Book Pages for Task 2 (print these pages for examples)

 

return to top  |  Performance Packages  |  Resources for Teachers  |  Site Overview

ã1999-2000 Monarchs in the Classroom  - University of Minnesota
Terms of Use